[ASKKPOP] English Demo of Girls' Generation "I Got A Boy" revealed online?

Recently, a video surfaced online containing a track bearing a very strong resemblance toGirls' Generation's "I Got A Boy". The vocals are unmistakably by UK based singerKaty Tiz.



Much like the Korean version, many K-Pop listeners will have a hard time deciphering the lyrics despite having any sort of mastery of the English language. The delivery is pretty intense and provides a tougher approach to the delivery than we're all used to.

Some fans are speculating whether or not this is merely a cover or a remix like the video suggests. However, it's more likely that the song is actually an earlier, unfinished version of Girls Generation's smash single with Katy Tiz serving as the vocal guide. To start, the recording is of studio quality. The resources used to create this track are unobtainable by fans or anyone other than persons with the rights for the track. Also, the fact that a recently signed recording artist, who isn't credited in the track's production credits, recorded the track hints that the demo was probably pitched to this artist for release before being sent toSM Entertainment. The real giveaway is in the Girls' album booklet where it states that the original title of the song was "Shiner On You", which Katy Tiz clearly sings in the chorus of her recording.

It's interesting to pick out and analyze the elements that SM incorporated to mold a track from a Norwegian production team into a multi-dimensional K-Pop track. Some fans have revealed their displeasure on SM for buying tracks from foreign producers rather than relying on their in-house production team. However, this proves the amount of additional layers of production and work that is involved in order to craft a song for their artists. Had the girls recorded Katy's version as is, the track wouldn't nearly be as spectacular in terms of weekly live performances or fitting to younger and conservative Korean audiences. If you guys want another example of SM revamping a track to suit their artists, check out the original version off(x)'s "Danger".



One more video worth checking out is a trackrumoredto be an instrumental of an upcoming collaboration byLady GagaandAzealia Bankstitled "Ratchet".



Personally, I don't believe Lady Gaga will be releasing her track with this instrumental or at least in the form that it's in now, but, the resemblance of this track (minus most of theTrapelements) to the electronic segments of "I Got A Boy" is striking nonetheless. Perhaps thissupposed "Ratchet" beat(no pun intended) is an even earlier draft of "I Got A Boy", which wouldn't be too farfetched knowing how music in the pop industry is recycled, clipped, and filtered through many hands before finally landing in a record.

Whether this Katy Tiz track is a previous demo or not, I think it gives us a good idea of what "I Got A Boy" might sound like in English. Most likely, they'll be re-writing the lyrics to reflect the girls' recording. So what are your thoughts on these tracks? Do you prefer Girls' Generation's version over Katy Tiz's? Let us know in the comments below.